Putting Bowser in Mario’s party is already a good reason for me to be curious about Super Mario RPG. Familiar characters become more interesting when they have to do a different job. The other attraction is the battle system: choosing a command does not mean putting the controller down until the animation ends. Timing still gives the player something useful to do.

Quick verdict

I would choose Super Mario RPG for a playful introduction to party battles that still gives timing a useful role.

Best for: Players who like Mario’s cast and want turn-based decisions with active attack and defence commands.

Main benefit: Action Commands connect a chosen move with a small moment of participation, while the party makes familiar characters work together.

Biggest drawback: The turn-based structure and party menus are a different activity from a Mario platformer, and the adventure may feel gentle to an experienced RPG player.

Super Mario RPG — 2023 US Nintendo Switch physical edition

Amazon US · US

Check price and availability: Super Mario RPG — 2023 US Nintendo Switch physical edition at Amazon US

Reviewed version: Super Mario RPG — 2023 US Nintendo Switch physical edition

Compatibility: Original Nintendo Switch physical game. Check the exact platform edition before purchase; separate Switch 2 editions, upgrade packs and expansion passes are different offers.

Review context: I assess the 2023 Switch remake, documented Action Commands, party structure, difficulty choice and changes from the earlier release.

This is the 2023 Nintendo Switch remake, released on 17 November, not the original Super NES edition. The selected Amazon US product identifies the Switch version. I would consider it as a playful way into party-based RPGs, while making clear that the activity is different from a Mario course built around running and jumping.

Nintendo promotional artwork shows Mario, Peach, Bowser, Mallow and Geno

Product images: Nintendo promotional artwork and official screenshots.

A command still has a moment of action

Nintendo’s battle explanation describes Action Commands: a timed input can strengthen an attack or help defend against one. I like that connection between choosing a move and carrying it out. It gives a turn-based battle a small physical rhythm without removing the time available to consider the next decision.

That makes the format appealing for someone who enjoys thinking before acting but does not want every outcome to happen at a distance. The player can decide what the party needs, then pay attention to a specific moment. Planning and participation have different jobs rather than competing for the same second.

I would not describe that as the same experience as a pure action game. Selecting commands and managing a party remain central. Someone buying only because Mario usually jumps directly when a button is pressed should understand the change. The familiar face is an invitation to a different structure, not a promise that every Mario game works alike.

Three active characters create a manageable team

The game uses a party of three in battle. I like that scale as a starting point. There is room for different jobs, while the player can still think about each person as an individual rather than one icon among a large crowd.

Nintendo’s character introduction makes the unusual group part of the appeal. Bowser joins Mario, alongside characters such as Mallow and Geno. That changes the usual relationships before a battle has even begun. A familiar opponent can become useful in a new way, and a new companion can give the story somewhere else to go.

For me, that is a better reason to care about party composition than a list of statistics alone. I would want to see what the combination lets the group do. A character can be enjoyable because of a role in a fight and because of a place in a joke. The lighter story tone gives those two attractions space to coexist.

Peach appears in Nintendo's official Super Mario RPG imagery

A well-timed move can support the next one

The remake adds a Chain system and an Action Gauge leading to Triple Moves, with the resulting move depending on the party. I like that a successful small action can contribute to something the group does together. It gives attention during an ordinary turn a purpose beyond making that one hit slightly stronger.

It also offers another way to explain teamwork. A party is not only three characters taking separate turns at the same opponent. The combination can create an action of its own. That is an understandable reward for paying attention to how the pieces fit.

My preferred approach would be to learn the ordinary attack and defence rhythm first. Once that is familiar, a gauge and a larger move have a clear place in the battle. Trying to optimise every system immediately can make an approachable game feel more complicated than the activity actually needs to be.

The world keeps Mario’s playful shape

The official imagery presents a bright, compact-looking world with familiar creatures and expressive characters. I like the small, almost toy-like scale because it suits an adventure built around a strange party and jokes. Not every RPG needs to communicate importance through a vast realistic landscape.

The launch article frames the journey around Star Road and the Smithy Gang. That gives the usual Mario cast a different situation to respond to. I would be interested in the changing roles, rather than buy only to see familiar locations drawn more sharply.

The movement between battles matters to that choice as well. Someone can enjoy exploring a bright place but dislike the transition into a separate fight. I would look at both activities in official footage. A recommendation based only on the character art would miss the structure that will occupy the player.

A remake can offer a choice about familiarity

Nintendo’s product page describes switching between the new and original soundtracks. I like that option in a remake. A returning player may want a familiar musical reference, while someone arriving now may prefer the new arrangement. Preserving a choice is more useful than assuming that every person wants the same relationship with an older game.

The documented Breezy difficulty also gives a buyer another way to judge the fit. I welcome a setting for someone more interested in the story and party than in a demanding battle. An experienced RPG player may value that differently, and should not mistake an approachable design for a promise of high difficulty.

Mario explores a green landscape in an official Super Mario RPG screenshot

There are later boss rematches for someone who wants another challenge after the story, but I would not buy mainly from a list of post-game tasks. The main reason to choose this remake is already clear: a small party, active timing and a lighter RPG mood. For someone who likes that combination, it is a more convincing offer than simply another game carrying Mario’s name.

What worked

Timed commands have a role in ordinary attacks and defending, rather than being confined to a few scripted scenes.

The new Triple Moves depend on the active party, giving its composition another visible purpose.

What bothered me

Someone who wants continuous running and jumping may find the transition into battles interrupts that expectation.

Who should not buy it

I would choose another game for a buyer mainly seeking a demanding platformer or simultaneous local co-op.

Alternatives I would consider

Super Mario Bros. Wonder. I would choose Wonder when the desired Mario activity is side-scrolling platforming and local shared play. Read my Super Mario Bros. Wonder review.

Xenoblade Chronicles 3. I would compare Xenoblade for a more elaborate real-time party system and a serious story tone. Read my Xenoblade Chronicles 3 review.

Evidence and sources

The linked publisher sources explain the game design and edition history. My recommendation is an editorial judgement; product images and edition listings provide the supporting reference material.

Features, compatibility and rated figures from the maker are manufacturer information. My opinions are identified in the review.

Conclusion

I would buy the 2023 Switch remake for its cheerful party and mixture of planning with timing. It makes more sense as a deliberately approachable RPG than as a purchase based only on a promise of maximum length or difficulty.

Super Mario RPG — 2023 US Nintendo Switch physical edition

Amazon US · US

Check price and availability: Super Mario RPG — 2023 US Nintendo Switch physical edition at Amazon US
Get the best articles from Think Different

One email a week with practical Mac workflows, useful comparisons and honest tech recommendations.