Super Mario Maker 2 appeals to the part of me that wants to understand why a small design works. A gap, a moving platform and one well-placed enemy can turn a simple route into a question. Here, the player can change that question instead of only answering it. I like that shift from following a course to deciding what a course should ask of someone else.
Quick verdict
I would choose Mario Maker 2 for someone who wants to make courses as well as play them.
Best for: Players interested in experimenting with a small idea, testing it and letting another person try it.
Main benefit: The course editor makes a familiar Mario obstacle into a creative decision the player can change.
Biggest drawback: Sharing and the wider online course catalogue depend on membership and the service remaining available.
Super Mario Maker 2 — original Nintendo Switch physical game
Amazon US · US
Check price and availability: Super Mario Maker 2 — original Nintendo Switch physical game at Amazon USAffiliate link. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Reviewed version: Super Mario Maker 2 — original Nintendo Switch physical game
Compatibility: Original Nintendo Switch physical game card. Check the exact console, language, controller and current software requirements. Newer console editions, downloadable additions and optional memberships are separate purchases.
Review context: I distinguish the built-in story, local course making and the online features with separate membership requirements.
This article concerns the original Nintendo Switch physical game, released on 28 June 2019 according to Nintendo. The selected Amazon US page identifies the US version. I would check the exact offer rather than assume it includes an online membership. The editor, built-in story and community features are related parts of the package, but their access conditions are not identical.

Product images: Nintendo promotional artwork and official game screenshots.
A familiar course becomes something to question
Nintendo describes a Course Maker with parts and tools for building side-scrolling Mario stages. What interests me is the chance to make a small idea visible quickly. A player can place an obstacle, decide where the landing should be, and consider what another person will understand from that arrangement.
That is a useful creative exercise even without a large ambition. I would start with one clear moment rather than a complicated level full of every available object. A course that introduces a small idea and gives it room can say more than a long sequence of unrelated surprises. The editor is attractive to me because it gives those choices a concrete form.
It also creates a different kind of value from simply counting how many courses are available. Someone interested in making and revising things may return to the same idea several times. Someone who has little interest in creating may care much more about the supplied stages. Those are both reasonable ways to judge the purchase, but they should not be confused.
The built-in story provides a place to start
Nintendo lists more than 100 built-in Story Mode courses. I like having that directed selection beside the editor. A completely open tool can be exciting and still leave a new user wondering what to do first. A defined set of courses gives the purchase another purpose before the player has their own project in mind.
I would not treat the story as an obligation to complete before making anything. The useful approach depends on the person. One player may want to see examples first. Another may immediately want to try placing a platform. The appeal of the package is having both options available, rather than requiring everyone to arrive with the same motivation.
For a gift, I would pay particular attention to whether the intended player enjoys showing an idea to someone else. A level editor can become a shared conversation about what is clear, surprising or frustrating. That social interest may be a stronger reason to buy than a general claim that a creative game is automatically educational.

Sharing has a real access condition
Nintendo’s current product page connects Course World, sharing and online multiplayer with the relevant Nintendo Switch Online membership. I would include that condition in the initial budget if those features are the main attraction. Buying a physical game card does not remove the membership requirement attached to online functions.
I would also check the current service information before paying mainly for a community catalogue. Online services have an ongoing role in that part of the purchase. The local editor and the built-in story are different reasons to own the game. A sensible buying decision should say which reason matters most to the household.
Community-made content adds variety, but I would expect different creators to have different audiences in mind. A course built to surprise an experienced player is not automatically a good first course for a beginner. I would be willing to help a new player choose suitable content instead of assuming every available stage provides the same welcome.
Making together is a different social activity
Nintendo documents cooperative course construction on one system. I like that possibility because two people do not have to compete to enjoy the same editor. They can disagree about where a platform belongs, try another arrangement and decide what the course is trying to achieve.
That still asks for patience. One person may enjoy explaining an idea while another simply wants a turn with the controls. I would not choose a creative tool as a guaranteed solution for every pair. Shared making works best when both people are interested in the process, not only in being the person who makes the final decision.
My main reservation is the openness of the activity. An editor gives a player freedom, but it also asks the player to supply an intention. If someone wants a carefully paced adventure with a clear next step, a directed Mario game may be a better purchase. More possibilities are useful only when they are possibilities the buyer actually wants.

The reason I would choose it
I would buy Mario Maker 2 for the chance to create a small, playable idea and let someone else respond to it. The built-in story makes the box easier to recommend, but the editor is the part that gives this release its particular identity. I would compare the current physical and digital offers, then add membership costs if sharing is part of the plan.
For a mainly directed platform adventure, I would choose Super Mario Bros. Wonder instead. For compact puzzles authored around a change of viewpoint, I would compare Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker. Mario Maker makes sense when the intended player wants some responsibility for the experience itself, including the work of making a course clearer and more enjoyable.
What worked
The built-in story provides a defined selection of courses alongside the editor.
Cooperative building gives two people a way to discuss a design on one system.
What bothered me
An open editor asks the player to supply ideas, and community courses vary in their intended audience.
Who should not buy it
I would choose a more directed Mario adventure for someone who wants a consistently curated path and has little interest in making courses.
Alternatives I would consider
Super Mario Bros. Wonder. I would choose Wonder for a directed platform adventure rather than an editor. Read my Super Mario Bros. Wonder review.
Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker. I would compare Captain Toad for compact, authored spatial puzzles without a course-making focus. Read my Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker review.
Evidence and sources
Nintendo’s product page establishes the release and documented features. My buying judgement weighs those design choices against the intended player, the exact edition and the total purchase.
Features, compatibility and rated figures from the maker are manufacturer information. My opinions are identified in the review.
Conclusion
I would buy it for the editor, with the built-in story as a useful second reason. I would include online membership only if sharing and community courses are part of the intended use.
Super Mario Maker 2 — original Nintendo Switch physical game
Amazon US · US
Check price and availability: Super Mario Maker 2 — original Nintendo Switch physical game at Amazon USAffiliate link. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
One email a week with practical Mac workflows, useful comparisons and honest tech recommendations.


